Lithograph of two figures holding each other

Couples Therapy · Psychotherapy Lisbon

It’s Not About the Dishes

Why a partner can do exactly what was asked and still leave the other unsatisfied, and what Lacan’s distinction between need, demand and desire explains about it.

Lithograph of two figures holding each other, in terracotta and black on cream paper
What two people who lack something offer each other anyway.

Love is giving something you don’t have to someone who doesn’t want it.

Jacques Lacan

One partner, tired, says: “You never help around here.” The other, a little stung, gets up and does the dishes. The kitchen is clean but the tension is still in the room.

The dishes were done. So what was left unanswered?

Around 1958, Jacques Lacan drew a distinction that could help explain this scene better. He distinguished three concepts that are often conflated: need, demand and desire.

Need: the biological

Need is the closest Lacan comes to what Freud called instinct. It is purely biological: hunger, thirst, tiredness. It arises for organic reasons and is discharged by one specific action, and then it goes quiet until the next time.

But an infant cannot satisfy its own needs. It is born helpless, entirely dependent on someone else to meet them. So the need has to travel: it must be expressed, and an other has to interpret it. A cry becomes a message, and someone has to decide what it means.

Demand: need addressed to someone

That expression is demand. The infant’s first demands may be nothing more than cries, but Lacan insists that even a cry is already organized symbolically. It is addressed, and it calls for an answer.

And here is where the decisive thing happens. The milk (the object) satisfies the hunger (the need), but it does not arrive on its own. It arrives from someone. A person chose to come, to respond, to give. The milk stops being only milk. It becomes proof that someone cares enough to come.

From then on, the object carries two meanings. One is practical: it feeds. The other is symbolic: it says you matter to me. The two do not carry equal weight, and the second tends to outweigh the first. Think of how the gesture of a gift can mean more than what is inside the box, or how a meal someone cooked for you tastes different from the same meal bought.

This is what Lacan means when he says demand has a double function. Every time we ask for something, we are asking for two things at once. We ask for the object, and we ask for the proof of love that comes with it. The first can be satisfied. The other person can provide objects, but they can never answer that demand unconditionally, because they too are divided; they have their own lacks, their own unanswered questions.

Desire: what is left over

This is where Lacan locates desire. A need can be met: you eat and the hunger is gone. But the demand for love cannot be met in the same way, because it asks for love without conditions, and no single gesture can prove that. So when the need has been satisfied, something is still unanswered. That remainder, what is left over after everything asked for has been given, is desire.

Lacan puts it as a kind of subtraction. Take the demand for love, remove the need that has been met, and what remains is desire. It is neither the hunger nor the request for love, it is the difference between them. That makes desire a different kind of thing from need. A need comes and goes: you get hungry, you eat, and it quiets down. Desire is always there, and it is not fulfilled so much as renewed, which is why we keep wanting even after we get what we asked for. And it is not really aimed at an object. It is tied to a lack, a sense that something is missing, and that is what keeps it in motion.

One caveat Lacan insists on is that this is not a straightforward sequence of events. We often imagine a baby who first experiences a pure, wordless need and only later learns to express it. A need becomes visible only after it has been expressed, and by then it is already tangled with the demand for love. The baby serves as a metaphor for a structure that Lacan argues is present in every request we make. For a couple, this means the lack that is felt is not something the partner is hiding or withholding.

What one is missing is not what is hidden in the other. This is the whole problem of love.

Jacques Lacan

Back to the kitchen

The request, clean plates, is on the register of need. The question underneath, do you see what I carry? would you do it without being asked?, is demand, the demand for love. And what is left after the dishes are done is desire.

That is why one partner can do exactly what was asked and still leave the other unsatisfied. The need was answered, but the demand for love cannot be met by any object, and what is left over simply persists. It is also why the other partner can feel baffled, even resentful: I did what you wanted. What more is there?

So what can we do with that, if no amount of dishes will settle it? The gap cannot be closed, but there is a lot to learn about how one stands in relation to it.

Wanting to be wanted

There is a further piece of Lacan’s account that matters especially for couples. He says that desire is always, in some way, the desire of the Other. In simpler terms: what we most want is to be wanted, to be recognized, to matter to someone.

That changes how a complaint sounds. “You never listen” or “you never initiate” is often a request to be wanted, and being wanted cannot be produced on command. A partner who does it because you asked has answered the need and missed the point.

It also means that desire does not simply arise from within. We learn what to want by sensing what others want, and in a couple we shape ourselves around what we imagine our partner wants from us. You might hold back because you think they find you too much, or try harder because you think they want something more. These guesses are rarely spoken and often wrong, yet they steer what we ask for. Much of the tension between two people exists there.

Two common traps

The first is to treat every demand as a verdict. Your partner is dissatisfied, and what you hear is you are failing. So you either defend yourself or work harder to please. Neither of those works, because you are answering a question that was never about your performance.

The second is to expect your partner to close the gap. For them to know without being told, to make you feel, finally, complete. When they cannot, it feels like betrayal. This is the structure of demand itself. The mother in the nursery could not answer it unconditionally, and neither can your partner in the kitchen.

Which leads to the part that is easy to miss: the gap is not a sign that something has gone wrong, it is actually where desire lives. A relationship in which every demand was perfectly met would not be a happier one.

What love does with the gap

Lacan has a striking definition of love: giving what one does not have to someone who does not want it.

It sounds paradoxical, but it describes something most couples know. Neither of you has the answer to the other’s question, and neither of you is complete. What your partner offers is never quite what you were asking for, and what you offer is never quite what they were asking for. And yet you give your attention, your presence and your care anyway, knowing it will not fill the gap.

That is what love is: what two people who lack something offer each other anyway.

What shifts

None of this means you should stop asking for things. Wanting love, attention and recognition is human, and a couple who cannot voice it probably has a different problem.

What can change is how a request is heard. A request that seems out of proportion starts to sound like a question, and the question becomes easier to hear. And a request you make yourself becomes easier to understand: you may notice that what you are really saying is closer to I just need to know you notice what I do.

This is why naming matters. Putting desire into words brings something new into existence between you. Speech can never say all of it, and a remainder always stays out of reach. But a couple who can say what they are really asking for tends to fight less about the dishes.

This way of listening is what psychoanalytic work offers a couple: not a technique for settling the argument, but a way of hearing the question inside it. Other approaches we use, such as Emotionally Focused Therapy and the Gottman Method, work on the same scene from a different angle.

If the pattern in your kitchen is one you have lived through before, in this relationship or an earlier one, that repetition is the subject of a workshop on 5 December: Here We Go Again!

Fighting about the dishes?

We work with couples in English, in Lisbon and online. The first session is a consultation, not a commitment.

Couples therapy in Lisbon

Source: Lacan, Jacques. The Seminar of Jacques Lacan, Book VIII: Transference (1960–1961). W. W. Norton & Company, 2015.
Written by Lea Eid, clinical psychologist, couples therapist and psychoanalyst (OPP nº32752), who works with individuals and couples in English and Arabic.


Lea Eid

Written by

Lea Eid

I am a clinical psychologist, couples therapist and psychoanalyst working with individuals, couples, and groups from a Lacanian psychoanalytic standpoint. I hold a Master's in Clinical Psychology, a professional license in clinical psychology, and a psychoanalytic formation. I am affiliated with Ordem dos Psicologos Portugueses (OPP), Collèges de Clinique Psychanalytique (CCPP) in Paris, and the Forums du Champ Lacanien (EPFCL/IF-EPFCL). I work in English and Arabic.

Continue Reading

5 Things Therapists Get Wrong With International & Expat Clients

Working Across Cultures 5 Things Therapists Get Wrong With International & Expat Clients Most clinical training happens inside one cultural…

Read: 5 Things Therapists Get Wrong With International & Expat Clients →

Types of Therapy: Find Your Path to Better Mental Health

Getting Started Types of Therapy: Find Your Path to Better Mental Health Whether you're struggling with anxiety, depression, or the…

Read: Types of Therapy: Find Your Path to Better Mental Health →

Transference-Focused Psychotherapy (TFP): What It Is and Who It Helps Most

Therapy Explained · TFP Transference-Focused Psychotherapy (TFP): What It Is and Who It Helps Most Transference-Focused Psychotherapy is a structured…

Read: Transference-Focused Psychotherapy (TFP): What It Is and Who It Helps Most →

Wondering if therapy could help with what you're dealing with?

Book a Consultation