Psychotherapy at the Movies · Film 1
The Cell (2000): Murderous Rage, Basements and the Unconscious on Screen
A film with a weak script and an extraordinary picture of the inner world. What Jennifer Lopez’s journey into a killer’s mind shows about murderous rage, defences, dissociation and the broken feelings of love underneath.

Spoilers and content note. This article discusses the plot of The Cell (2000), including its ending. The film contains violence and images of child abuse. We describe them in general terms, without graphic detail.
In The Cell, directed by Tarsem Singh, Jennifer Lopez plays Catherine Deane, a child therapist who uses experimental technology to enter the minds of her patients. When a serial killer, Carl Stargher (Vincent D’Onofrio), falls into a coma, she is asked to go inside his mind to find out where his latest victim is being held, before time runs out.
It is the kind of premise that sounds ridiculous in a sentence, and the film is, in many ways, not good. But it is one of the few mainstream films that tries to show what the unconscious is actually like, and several things it shows are close to what we see in the consulting room. This is the first article in a series about films in which you can discover interesting psychotherapeutic themes. We start with this one, and we read it through the lens of ISTDP, Intensive Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy.
A weak script, a dream that works
You can criticise the screenplay as much as you like. The plot is thin, the dialogue is functional, and the film is happy to treat mental illness as a source of monsters. But the costumes (by Eiko Ishioka) and the surreal, dream-like quality of the world of the unconscious show, in a very beautiful way, how we dream, and what difficult things lie in the corners of our psyche. Images that do not follow ordinary logic, rooms that open onto other rooms, figures who are dressed to express a feeling rather than a person. That is how the unconscious presents itself, in dreams and in therapy.
The one pity is that the film does not show the inner world of its heroine in the same detail. Catherine walks through Carl’s mind as an observer, and we never see her own corners. It is reasonable to assume that we would find similarly difficult material there, because everyone has it. We come back to this below, because it matters for how therapists work.
The basement: the unconscious as architecture

A common way to picture the unconscious is a house. Upstairs is the self we show during the day. Downstairs are the rooms we keep locked: feelings, memories and impulses that were once too painful or too dangerous to feel. The Cell builds exactly this, as a series of landscapes, cells and chambers, each one holding a different part of Carl.
In ISTDP the idea is a little more precise. What is unconscious is not random. It holds feelings tied to early attachment relationships, and it stays out of awareness because feeling them produces anxiety, and because the mind learns defences against that anxiety. The therapist’s task is to help the patient reach those feelings in a way the patient can bear and use. You can read more about the approach on our ISTDP page.
Murderous rage
The central figure of the underworld in the film is a ruler of Carl’s mind, a cruel king who dominates everything. In ISTDP language we would say that Carl is a man in whom the rage that arose from early abuse has never been felt, processed or put in its place. It has taken over.
ISTDP uses the term murderous rage for something that is, in a much milder and almost always non-violent form, present in many people who were hurt, neglected or frightened as children. It is rage towards the people closest to them, the attachment figures, and it is unconscious because feeling it would threaten the bond with someone the child needed. In therapy it can appear as vivid fantasies, and as sensations in the body, when the defences soften.
The important thing, and the thing the film gets in a distorted way, is where the rage goes. In the great majority of patients it never turns into harm to others. It turns against the self: depression, self-sabotage, chronic guilt, physical symptoms. Carl is an extreme case, in which the rage is acted out, and the film’s king is what we call identification with the aggressor, a person who becomes the thing that hurt him. You can read more about how we work with feelings on our page on emotions in ISTDP.
Torture, in fantasy and in fact
The film’s most disturbing images are scenes of cruelty inside Carl’s kingdom. They look strange to us in the cinema, but fantasies of violence, even of torture, are a recognised form of what rage looks like when it first becomes conscious. A patient may suddenly see an image of hurting someone who hurt them, and be horrified by it.
This is where the distinction between feeling and acting is the whole point of the work. An image of violence in the mind is not an intention. It is the shape a feeling takes. Patients are often relieved, after the first shock, to learn that they can feel it, say it out loud and survive it, and that nothing has to be done with it. Carl’s tragedy is that nobody ever helped him to feel it, so the only form it could take was action.
Broken feelings of love
The emotional centre of the film is not the king. It is the frightened child that Catherine finds in a corner of Carl’s mind. The film understands something that surprises many people: underneath the rage there is not more rage. There is attachment, and the grief of a love that was broken.
In ISTDP, when a patient truly feels the rage, a sequence tends to follow. Guilt appears, because the rage is directed at someone who was also loved or needed. Then comes grief, for the loss of a relationship that could have been, and for the childhood that did not happen. The feelings are mixed, rage and love towards the same person. A great deal of suffering comes from not being able to hold both at once, so one of them has to go underground.
Dissociation and defences
Carl’s mind is split into a child and a king, and the film shows this literally. In clinical language this is splitting, and it is closely related to dissociation: parts of experience are kept separate, because they cannot be held together. The coma itself is a kind of ultimate dissociation, a withdrawal from the world.
In ISTDP, dissociation also appears as one of the ways anxiety shows up in the body. A patient may suddenly feel unreal, lose the thread of what they were saying, or find that their vision blurs. These are signs that anxiety has risen to a level where the mind is protecting itself by switching off, and the therapist has to respond to them differently from other kinds of anxiety. We describe the pathways on our page about anxiety in ISTDP, and the defences in more detail on the page about defences.
What the film gets right about the therapist
A few things in Catherine’s work are close to something real. She does not stay on the surface. She goes towards the feeling instead of discussing it from a distance. She makes contact with the vulnerable part, the child, rather than arguing with the frightening part, because it is the vulnerable part that makes a working alliance possible. And she is affected by what she finds. A therapist who works with this kind of material is not a neutral camera.
That last point links back to the pity mentioned above. The film shows Carl’s inner landscape in detail and Catherine’s not at all, as if the therapist were a clean window. In reality every therapist has their own basement, and the way they work is shaped by whether they have looked into it. This is the reason serious training in this field includes the therapist’s own therapy and supervision, and it is one of the reasons we regard our own work with it as a necessary part of the job rather than an extra.
What the film gets wrong
First, therapists do not enter a patient’s mind. ISTDP happens in a room, with a person who consents, is awake and is a partner in the work. The patient’s conscious cooperation, which we call the therapeutic alliance, is the engine of the whole process. Nothing can be done to an unwilling mind.
Second, the film treats an inner conflict as something to be resolved by ending a part of the person. In its final movement Catherine brings the story of the child to an end inside the dream, and the man dies in the real world. In real therapy the aim is the opposite: to feel what was split off and integrate it, not to destroy it.
Third, and most important, the film connects mental illness with violence, and trauma with monstrosity. The great majority of people who have lived through abuse never harm anyone, and people with schizophrenia are far more likely to be victims of violence than perpetrators. If the film leaves you with one false idea, let it not be that.
The Cell shows what happens when rage that was never felt is acted out. The rest of us, in therapy, are working on the far more common story: rage that was never felt and went inwards.
If you recognise some of this in yourself, for example a self-critical voice that never lets up, a feeling of being cut off from your own emotions, or a pattern that repeats in your relationships, our page about the first ISTDP session explains what the process looks like in practice.
Curious about this kind of work?
We offer ISTDP, couples therapy, EFT and integrative therapy online, and in person in Lisbon. The first session is a consultation, not a commitment.
Sources and further reading: The Cell, directed by Tarsem Singh, New Line Cinema, 2000. Davanloo, H. (1990). Unlocking the Unconscious: Selected Papers of Habib Davanloo, M.D. Wiley. Abbass, A. (2015). Reaching Through Resistance: Advanced Psychotherapy Techniques. Seven Leaves Press. See also our articles on Habib Davanloo and the research on ISTDP.
This article is part of the series Psychotherapy at the Movies. It is a reading of a work of fiction and not clinical advice or a diagnosis of any real person.
Continue Reading
Is It the Right Time to Start Therapy?
Before You Start Is It the Right Time to Start Therapy? Most people wait longer than they need to, often…
Read: Is It the Right Time to Start Therapy? →Online Couples Therapy for Long-Distance and Expat Relationships: Does It Actually Work?
Online Couples Therapy for Long-Distance and Expat Relationships: Does It Actually Work? Relationships are hard enough when you’re in the…
Read: Online Couples Therapy for Long-Distance and Expat Relationships: Does It Actually Work? →CBT Therapy: What It Is, How It Works, and Who It Helps Most
Therapy Explained · CBT CBT Therapy: What It Is, How It Works, and Who It Helps Most Cognitive Behavioural Therapy…
Read: CBT Therapy: What It Is, How It Works, and Who It Helps Most →Wondering if therapy could help with what you're dealing with?
Book a Consultation